Mainstream Media Feeling Threatened by Bloggers at CES

by Teresa Valdez Klein on January 11, 2007

Our good buddy Jeremiah Owyang wrote about a reported incident in the press room at CES. Obviously, this is coming from a third-hand source, so keep that in mind when making judgments about the relative accuracy of the account. As Jeremiah tells it:

In one case, I heard that in the CES press room a discussion occurred where one blogger told another that they prefer to read blogs to get news, rather than traditional press.

A member of the traditional press got really upset, raised his voice, causing much of the table to look over, and he left in a furious stomp. It was suggested that he felt his job was threatened.

I understand why the mainstream media feels threatened by this new medium, but I don’t think their worries are credible in the long term. The blogosphere is a really nice compliment to traditional media, but it will never replace it.

As Shel Israel told me, CNN can embed an intrepid reporter with a group of soldiers in a combat zone. Political bloggers can be armchair warriors, but they can’t report directly what’s happening on the front lines. Yes, soldiers blogging gives us a perspective on the war. But soldiers are doing their job soldiering. That doesn’t leave them a lot of time to investigate and report the way a traditional journalist can.

I think in time, most reporters worth their salt will start their own blogs either for personal use, or to flesh out information about their recent work. Newspaper editors are always cutting fascinating pieces out of articles for space reasons or because the piece of the story in question is interesting but tangential. Those are the kinds of tidbits that journalist-bloggers would be uniquely poised to provide. It’s just another way that blogging adds value to the mainstream press without compromising it.

Share and Enjoy: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Netscape
  • StumbleUpon
  • TailRank
  • NewsVine
  • Reddit

{ 6 comments… read them below or add one }

1

shel israel 01.11.07 at 8:49 pm

Trad media doesn’t understand that it’s asset is a news gathering organization that bloggers cannot yet match. What they do not understand is the liability driving them to the edge of continued existence is the expensive antiquated delivery system of papers, being tossed onto the world’s doorsteps. The paper is what’s killing them.

2

Teresa Valdez Klein 01.12.07 at 1:01 pm

Shel: I get that, although I have to tell you that the paper is really relaxing to read. Call me old school, but I really enjoy reading the newspaper in the morning before I get online. I love the Web, but the paper lets me really focus on what I’m reading.

3

Graeme Thickins 01.14.07 at 7:35 am

Great post, Teresa, and nice meeting you at the blogger party on Jan 9! It was fun, and great networking. Thanks also to Jeremiah for his post starting this discussion.

I agree with you — nothing against blogs, but the paper is still a ritual for me every morning, too. I especially will always read the WSJ that way, even though I also pay for an online subscription. And, as my friend Rich Karlgaard told me recently, Forbes will never give up the magazine, but all the growth is in online.

No question these are times of great flux in the newspaper and magazine industry.

cheers,
Graeme

4

Dennis McDonald in Alexandria Virginia 01.14.07 at 7:57 am

I agree with Shel. The infrastructure surrounding paper is killing them. The sooner that newspapers learn that they are in the news business, not the print-the-news-on-paper-and-distribute-the-paper business, the better off they will be. Like Google, though, they need to figure out a way to deliver news AND advertising simultaneously, otherwise they will have to load all their costs onto subscribers.

5

Renee Blodgett 01.14.07 at 7:15 pm

I most definitely felt a difference this year vis a vis other years. Having done 10+ CES’s, more than that number of Comdexes and Demos, and 90% of the blog conferences in the biz, I’ve spent a chunk of time on both sides. I wrote about it here pertaining to CES this year
http://www.downtheavenue.com/2007/01/old_media_new_m.html

For me, it was more personal, which apparently didn’t come across in this post according to a few blogger/reporter friends. Connection to community resonates with all of us and there’s no question, many of us are getting pulled in a lot of different directions right now.

Renee

6

steven e. streight aka vaspers the grate 01.15.07 at 1:18 pm

I’m so tired of hearing how “professional”, “indispensable”, and “threatened” the MSM is. Why don’t they just die already?

I go to the MSM news for entertainment, not facts.

These “brave” reporters in war zones don’t venture out to personally witness very much. All these MSM jerks keep saying is how many American military have been killed today.

The scumbags.

No report on how many schools and hospitals are up and running. No report on how many girls are getting an education. No report on the outlying provinces. Not much on Afghanistan.

Just Baghdad Baghdad Baghdad.

A typical MSM report is CNN’s fraudulent coverage of the Iraq elections, showing old footage of terrorist carnage and Iraqis wailing in grief. Then a “will this play out again today?” as if they almost hoped it would.

Lies and distortions, and a perpetual focus on celebrities and Hellywood “stars”.

When something major happens, I go to Instapundit and other journalist blogs. The MSM coverage is weak and usually worthless.

Leave a Comment

You can use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <p> <strike> <strong>